Originally posted by kenny
No. An internal modem is not neccessary to get an external device working like this. The 2 are completely independent devices. Adding an internal modem is a waste of time and money in this situation.
You mentioned that it worked with your PowerBook, but not your desktop machine. There are a few things you can look for to correct this...
1. Is the desktop machine running the same version of the OS as the PB? Apple has continually added support for various devices over the different updates. For example, if your PB is running 10.2.4, you should make sure that your desktop machine is too.
Both are running X.2.4. Both have the same version of TA driver installed.
2. Have you checked System Profile with the new TA attached? Is it showing up? Are you connecting directly to the machine or through a USB hub? I've seen all kinds of problems with cheap hubs preventing things appearing as they should.
Yes, it's there. I've tried connecting through a hub and directly, that makes no difference. Then again, just seeing the device in the System Profile doesn't mean that you can use it. The previous TA I had was also visible, it just didn't work with X.
3. Have you quit out of System Preferences completely? I noticed that with Bluetooth, the prefs wouldn't appear unless System Prefs were quit and then reopened.
4. Logout/Restart. If none of the rest of this works, try logging out and logging back in with the TA attached. I've also seen problems with new usb devices showing up unless I logged out/in. If all else fails, restart with the TA attached and powered-on.
I've tried quitting, restarting, logging in, you name it. Nothing seems to help.
I've been working with Mac's for about 10 years now. I've seen all kinds of weird problems with peripherals, but this is the first time I'm willing to wave a white flag, raise my hands, and walk out.
Again, the internal modem has nothing to do with this, but hopefully one of these suggestions will help. Let us know how you get on...
I admit that it sounds crazy. Why indeed should I need an internal modem? I just can't figure out any other solutions. I'll try it this weekend, and if it doesn't work I'll call Apple helpline (47 or dollars / phone call). Call that surrendering, if you like.
-Janne