Both are simple to install. Should take less than 5 minutes. Even if you had one with jumpers, still simple. The PL I have doesn't have jumpers. Performance about the same. Powerlogix is supposed to have bad tech support from threads I've read. I contacted them once right after I bought my upgrade because they came out with a newer version, same speed, but higher cache. They had me send mine back and they replaced it with the newer one, and they even paid for shipping both ways. People seem to like both GigaDesigns and Mercury Extreme the best.
You get a 3 year warranty with all of them except PL, (2 year), so you shouldn't have any problems that way.