symphonix said:
Of course, now that I think about it, Apple co-founder and former board member Steve Wozniak has put out a mobile phone based product a few years back (remember the Hiptop aka Sidekick?). It wasn't a great hit, but for the time it was actually a really cool device. I suspect what really hurt its sales was existing phone makers under-selling their handsets at below cost as part of their agreements with telcos, and telcos refusing to offer the required services (WAP, GPRS, etc) at a price any sane person would want to pay.
The hiptop is one cool device!
I would love to have one but it has several shortcomings
1. Data only works if the provider has a Danger server backend to serve compressed pages - if you unlock it you cannot use it, except as a phone, in a different carrier
2. No removable media
3. Apps not openly available - only downloadble over the network. No download/installation over PC/Mac available
4. POOR mac support
5. Poor sync support
If these were not issues, and more devices came out it would have been more of a success.
And then, there was the Motorola deal which brought us iTunes on the ROKR. This also was something that Apple would rather forget. The phone started out promising, but the RIAA, the Telcos, Motorola and Apple could not agree on what the product should be, so we ended up with a phone with pitiful storage and a hard-coded limit of 100 songs.
I agree that the telcos and the gang have killed the phone BUT
100 songs are OK. Battery life of a phone considering talk time, SMS, web-browsing and music listening take a toll on the battery. I have 2000 songs on my 20GB iPod. I am under the storage limit - and on top of that I only listen to about 100-150 songs in my commute everyday. If you want to mix it up you can have a randomizer and sync with your mac daily to get different/varied songs.
While I know Apple will be watching this frontier closely, I don't see them getting involved in phones again any time soon. Its taken every bit of legal nouse and negotiation just to get video on the iPod, and if you add in the telcos that want to make money off ringtones, the RIAA and MPAA, then you have a nightmare scenario.
Its not technology thats holding us back at the moment, its lawyers.
Telcos can make money off the data required to download tunes.
Apple and moto COULD have integrated the store in the phone so that they could sell music OTA using the telco's network - some telcos are greedy though and want BOTH data usage revenue and song revenue - can't have it both ways.
I would say apple could dip back in - but maybe not that soon.