ElDiabloConCaca said:
Or, quite possibly, because this is everyone's first experience with EFI (the BIOS replacement) besides the developers. It takes time to reverse-engineer EFI, then figure out how to boot an operating system that has no EFI support on an EFI machine.
Possibly?
Hmm, I guess if you want to play the sarcasm game I can do that.
Do you think that the people that hacked OSx86 had experience with TPM? I am _absolutely_ sure that all they had to do was throw the disk in, install and blow away the TPM kext... yea it was that simple, no reverse-engineering required. Definitely. As I recall it actually required a rather cumbersome process involving PearPC and VMWare. If I could find the original instructions I would post them.
Furthermore, while EFI is new, it is also an open standard and a lot of documentation can be found on
Intel's site. I don't think it's the reverse-engineering is what is slowing them down, I think its the fact that there aren't a lot of hackers out there with Intel Macs. OSx86 was hacked quickly but all it required was a run of the mill PC. How many people do you know that have an Intel Mac? How many hackers do you know that have an Intel Mac? While the prize for winning is quite nice, I'm not sure I would plop down $1500 bucks for a chance to win because who knows how many other people doing the same thing.
While I am not saying your point is invalid, I just don't think it's the major issue. I however do not understand how closely Windows and BIOS work together in the early stages of booting, you are right this could be very complicated, if not impossible. That all depends on how much interaction goes on between the two. If BIOS simply finds what to boot from and executes it I couldn't see getting this to work with EFI being super complex. Basically modify something like GRUB to boot from EFI and allow selection of XP and OS X. If it's more complicated and there is a lot more information exchanged, some sort of emulation might be necessary. Although
it looks like gateway already has XP booting from EFI.
Now I mustn't worry about this any more. It is 5:00A.M. and I have an exam to study for.
That was interesting, I haven't gotten into a mini flame war in a while.