Filevault performance?

Zaphod_B

Just me :)
I like the idea of Filevault on my 12" PB carrying my personal files. However, I'd like to know first how much this will impact my performance in a negative manner. Anyone has some experiences to share? How much CPU does it take? Extra HDD activity perhaps?

I did search the forum, there isn't a lot of discussion on Filevault. Not too much people using it? Or is just everybody so happy with it that it ain't worth discussing? ;)
 
I don't notice any overhead - but then again I didn't use my PB much before I enabled it so I'm not sure on that. (I need more RAM!)

Every now and then when I go to shut down - it asks me if I want to recover drive space (something about File Vault using more than necessary). That annoys the heck out of me! Wish it just DID it then shut down on it's own without asking! :p

I'm not sure if this is a File Vault problem or not, but in Font Book I can't activate my user fonts (in ~/Library/Fonts).

Other than that, I wouldn't be caught dead without File Vault on my PB! If my PB gets lost or stolen - they are not getting to my data or client files! (first they'd have to survive a confrontation with me tho! :D)
 
I did switch it on now. It took near to forever (90 mins) but it is working now, without trouble at all. Only annoyance is indeed these messages about recovering drivespace. I did some trial & error on it, and I found out that it wants to do this as soon as the used space in your homedir is less than the size of the diskimage it is using to store your homedir in. In other words:

- Let say you have 235 MB of data in your Homedir
- You convert it to FileVault. This creates an encrypted disk image of exactly 235 MB and puts all your files in your homedir in
- You add 15 MB of data to your homedir. The FileVault diskimage is automagically extended to hold this extra data, so the disk image is now 250 MB.
- You remove 2 MB of data from your homedir. When you logout FileVault whines about recovering data. What is going on?
- your filevault disk image is 250 MB
- the size of the data in it is 248 MB
- the filevault software calcs: 250-248=2, which is > 0 --> so we need to recover something.

Sounds like Apple needs to work on some improvement here. I think it is ok if the 'delta' is 50 MB or more that it suggest to recover. But not for 2 MB, that is ridiculous, since you work on files everyday. You don't want to recover filespace everyday.

Maybe for people working with large files everyday this limit should be even higher. Apple should make it a preference which a user should be able to set for him/herself.

For the rest, FileVault works like expected. It is as fast as without, no glitches noticable. And it gives me some nice feeling of extra security :). (which is probably ridiculous because if it gets stolen (heaven forbids!!!), the thief won't be interested in my personal crap, he just wants the hardware. he will probably format it right away to erase tracks...)

Anyway, just in case the thief is more creative, FileVault gives some extra feeling of protection that I like.

Don't forget to make regular backups on CD's or so....
 
I think a better solution, and one I use even though I don't have filevault is to store big drive space hogs like divx's and mp3's and photo's in a directory other then your home. All I have in my home directory are my pref files, my documents folder, I have links set up from pictures, movies, music, and they help. Unless you want all your music and other things encrypted (I don't see why) it would be a time saver to set it up like me.
 
As I'm using the Desktop for almost everything, FileVault is a no-go for me. Plus: Remember that you have to always logout before you let somebody steal your PowerBook, because only then your files are safe. :P
 
Screen saver come up after 5 mins, password protected. So is Password Protection after sleep.
Hmmm... maybe I should also set "logout after x minutes". :p
 
Log out after x minutes was one of the features apple made to improve filevault performance I think.
And toast - with some aliases/soft links you can have everything still on your desktop but then not actually in your home directory. I maintain the default tree structure of my home, I just keep all the actual data in /Users/Shared.
 
Back
Top