Hard drive errors, boot keys, and 2nd drive

davemac

Registered
Hello all,

I bought a new SATA 120Gb Maxtor hard drive last week, and installed it into my PowerMac Dual 1.8 G5. It was working fine for a week; I had copied most of my computers data to it. On Saturday it gave me an access error while copying a file. At first I thought nothing of it, but then it happened again to a different file a few hours later. Finally while downloading a file to the 2nd hard drive Finder completely locked up. I let the computer sit for a while and when I came back it was still frozen. My only option was to kill the power.

When it turned back on the 2nd hard drive was not mounted on the desktop. I ran disk utility and tried to verify but was told that the drive needed to be repaired. When I attempted repair it told me Disk utility stopped repairing. "The underlying task reported failure on exit". Most of the files I had copied were backed up, so I just decided to reformat the hard drive (zero rewrite).

After the hard drive reformat was done I ran verify and repair again with the same results. I used a copy of Disk Warrior to check the 2nd hard drive and about half way through the process it froze. Not wanting to worsen the situation I let it sit for nearly 24 hours hoping it would complete, but eventually I had to power off again.

When I booted back up the drive was not mounted again. I tried to reboot using the Disk Warrior CD and noticed that OSX was IGNORING ALL OF MY BOOT KEYS. I attempted 'C' to boot from the CD, CMD+OPT+SHFT+DEL to ignore the hard drive, CMD+OPT+P+R, Safe-Mode SHIFT... none of them worked. I inserted my Tiger CD and clicked the install button which told the computer to reboot. Once it was up I ran disk utility from the Tiger CD. Then, purely on accident, I ran verify on my main hard drive. It also reported errors, and when I ran repair, I was given the exact same error messages as above.

My Disk Warrior CD is good, as verified in another computer, but it will not boot the problem machine. I was hoping for a just bad hard drive all weekend, but things are starting to look worse and worse. I am going to try to test the hard drive in another computer this afternoon then change my boot options to use the Disk Warrior CD, but I am not sure what will be the result of either of these attempts.

Help, please.
 
3 more tries in another G5 of Partition, Erase, Verify & Repair all produced errors.

Still doesn't explain the boot key issues though.
 
I had a similar problem with my G4 Powerbook recently. It would freeze, the screen would go out, it wouldnt start up. So i ran the Tiger disk for Disk utility and i got a message "Fatile Hard Drive error. Back-up your information as soon as possible and replace the hard drive."

Back in the US i was scheduled to leave in 1 week to Cyprus. Apple was no help becaue they would just send the laptop to their shop and that would take like 2 weeks. I found someplace to do it locally. Lucky for me I had the extended warnety.

Acording to the workers, I had a bad Hard Drive. it was rare 1 in every 1000 i think or more.

Bottom line you need to replace it. Data Rescue 2 (II) should help. It lets you boot up from the disk and get to the Disk utility. After that, you can back-up the files to a jumpdrive (USB), external HD, etc. and even an iPod. If you send it to Apple without a warrenty it wil take lotsa $$$ (or in Britain £££) out of your pocket. Also you could go through Apple and have them save the data but it may cost more. My local Apple shop sold the Data Rescue II.

Best of luck to you.

Also, I only know of the C boot key.
 
Back
Top