Convert said:
Can I ask why? I have always wondered if there would be much of a benefit having it else where.
A few reasons. None really major, but enough to make a crotchety interface nitpicker like me hate it at the bottom
:
1. Vertical screen real estate is generally more valuable than horizontal. Most things, like web pages and text files, scroll vertically, and do not need to fill the entire width of the screen. I want to be able to view as much of my stuff at a time as possible. Also, screens are wider than they are tall, especially with Apple's wide screens. This was more important on my old smaller monitor, but even on my current 1280x1024 LCD, it's worth something.
2. I usually don't want my windows going all the way to the right, anyway, because I like my desktop icons to be visible. The bottom of the screen is just more useful to applications than the right (see 1.)
3. Force of habit, I guess. When I used OS 8/9, I put my Application floater at the top-right (for reasons 1 and 2), and since I use my Dock pretty much like an Application Floater on crack (more like Application Floater + FinderPop substitute, really), I like it in the top-right, too. Back in OS 8/9, the Control Strip always drove me crazy at the bottom, too.
And a bonus reason
:
4. At the bottom, it's too close to my windows' resize boxes and, as jsavoor mentioned, scroll bars. I don't find this a problem at the right, because as I said, most windows don't demand the full width of the screen anyway. On the other hand, most windows
will benefit from all the height you can give them, so you'll usually have them pressed right up against the Dock if it's at the bottom.
BTW, one thing I hate about the dock, no matter which side it's anchored to, is the way it stays in the center, so everything moves around as items are added to it. Using a third-party program like TinkerTool, you can access the Dock's hidden feature that lets you anchor it to a specific corner. I find it much more efficient this way, because my application icons will always stay
exactly where I put them. It requires less time and attention to get what you want when it's always in the same place. Try it; you'll like it!