Here's the general breakdown.
⢠PC's are good for gaming if you want popular games when they come out, or games that will never meet any large cats, like Counterstrike or Battlefield 1942. They are good because they are *cough* easily upgradeable and they can connect you with thousands of different people all over the world. The disadvantage (besides they are not Macs) is that they are somewhat impersonal (irony for ya), they run Windows and they need the latest greatest hardware to run the latest greatest games, all at top dollar.
⢠Macs are good for gaming if you want some choice, quality titles, lesser known games like most of Ambrosia's offerings, or don't want to support Microsoft in the least. Advantages are on par with those of PC's: easy to upgrade, worldwide reach, plus ease of use and reliability. Disadvantages: it's a PC world meaning fewer titles, less support and less hardware; they are also machines you use alone, and they are somewhat pricey.
⢠Consoles are good for gaming because that is their sole purpose in life. (What I wouldn't pay for a PS2 that ran Photoshop!) They are cheap, idiot-proof and good for easily setting up a LAN-like situation with some friends or family. The disadvantages are mostly the advantages of computers: they don't go online in any fashion near that of computers, they can't connect you worldwide, they (for the most part) can't be upgraded, and they can't run anything else.
In any case, Mac and PC gaming aren't going anywhere. For one thing, computers lend themselves better to titles like Myst etc., Ares, Diablo etc., and so on. Many people also enjoy tricking out their systems with the latest greatest technology. (How many people do you know who have tinkered with their cars?) Computers do other tasks besides games, and modification is a piece of cake. Consoles are tweaked specifically for games and rarely if ever crash, yet they run the latest software for $300 or less. Of course, TV resolution is not as sharp, bright or colorful as a computer monitor, but they are bigger; also, gamepads lend themselves well to certain kinds of games (racing, sports, RPG's) but flounder on others (Medal of Honor with a joystick? Please!). In any case, each option has certain ramifications that must be considered when gaming, none is perfect, and none is going to go away any time soon.