I've got my iMac G5 ...

symphonix

Scratch & Sniff Committee
... and I'm very pleased. As promised I'll be posting a review of some of the most critical questions that people have been asking, and that I have been wondering about.

First: the Specs
17" G5 1.8ghz | 512mb RAM | 160GB HDD | Bluetooth Keyboard and Mouse | Airport Extreme card | Airport Express base station.

Well, due to a slight problem I didn't get the Airport Extreme card on the day, as I'd ordered it as an afterthought and it was set aside for me, and the manager didn't know where the guy I dealt with had hidden it! He'll have it couriered up to me on Monday morning. :)

That said, I'll move on to the bad points. Dead pixel count: one. It's on the leftmost edge of display, and is practically invisible, but its there. I'm not going to worry about it.
Point two: noise. Its certainly quieter than my G3 iBook, and my PC at work, and just about ANY computer I've ever used. In fact, its very quiet. But the noise it does make has a habit of changing as the fans are constantly adapting their speed to meet the demands of the processor. Its completely inaudible in the calm of night working on a few docs and web pages and stuff, but if you kick in an intensive task like a complicated Keynote or iDVD task, you'll hear the faint sound of the fans picking up the pace. Its still quieter than any other machine I've used, but the constantly changing sound takes a day to get used to.

Now for the good points. Packaging was smart and well designed. I note that the protective sheet on the stand had tabs clearly designed to be easy to find and pull off. Setup was flaswlessly smart. The first thing that appears on switching on is a graphic showing the user how to put batteries in the mouse and switch it on (batteries ARE included, and they're good ones, which makes the whole experience feel better). Once you've done this, the mac finds the mouse and tells you to "click here to continue", and a similar process follows for the keyboard. Setup, registration and so on is complete in around 3 minutes, and that includes putting in your language and regional settings (the time is set automatically). Very nice.

Bootup time is around 15 seconds. I tried throwing just about everything at it and the only thing that seemed to fall over was issuing a few too many commands at the same time in iDVD. Obviously iDVD still has a way to come for stability.

One major question floating around is the position of the ports. Let me say this: it's perfect. I currently am using only one port ... the modem port, since my AE hasn't arrived yet. I've also plugged in a USB key and a digicam, and the whole unit is so easy to move you can just spin it and plug them in without having to get out of your seat.

The appearance of the machine is something that only works in real life, photos just don't capture the slick transparent shell. Even the power plug has been finished in the same material. Its easy to move around, to push it from side to side and tilt it to your needs.

The 17" display is very nice and big and colourful. I will say this though: it looked AWFUL fresh out of the box, and required a recalibration and tweaking of the font-smoothing settings to get right. The "out-of-the-box" setting is for CRTs and does not look right. Once adjusted though, the display is SWEEEEEET.

The drive is quick and easy to find, even in the dark. I've heard people complain that you have to look for the drive to put CDs in, this is utter nonsense. You can just slam them in there, since the slot is integrated into the shell in such a way that there isn't so much as a single bump or seam that could lead you astray.
Aside from that, the keyboard is small and VERY heavy, quiet to type on, and has the best little rubber feet to keep it solid as a rock on your desk.
I've been using the wireless mouse only, in spite of having a rather nice Logitech one waiting to be plugged in that I thought I'd prefer. The mouse even has a two-level adjustable click pressure (inside the battery cover), and the operating range is well outside the house, which is simply overkill.

Sound is great, though the maximum level might be a little low for the younger generation. It certainly is more than loud enough for comfortable listening.

All in all, the new iMac has surpassed my expectations and is a delight to use. I'd recommend it to anybody looking for a computer. I love it!
 

Attachments

  • MyG5iMac.jpg
    MyG5iMac.jpg
    61.5 KB · Views: 39
Great review. Thank you for that!

But looking at the pic, I am still unsure about the actual design. I would get the iMac for pure practical application: G5, small form factor, but it does look kinda plain.
 
I'd be happy to run some performance tests, if anyone can think of anything.
In my opinion, it is fantastically fast, with iDVD rendering complex animations instantly, and apps like Keynote, Word, and so on running like a dream. It'll rip CD-Audio at a rate of 45mins of audio in under 2 mins of processing to AAC. GarageBand can perform most of its operations in less than a heartbeat. I have yet to load up a lot of games and so on, though, as its been a very busy week at work. Maybe for the weekend!

As for the appearance, I brought it into the office and everybody is really impressed with the look of the thing. Most people commented "Wow, what a beautiful monitor!", needless to say they were a little stunned to learn that it was in fact the whole computer.

The shell is a nice, glossy white which matches with just about all existing Apple hardware, and has a 4-5mm layer of transparent polycarbonate OVER the white inner shell. The effect is quite simply stunning in the flesh, but over 20 attempts to capture the spirit of the design in a digital photo all failed miserably. Photos just don't do it justice, not even the ones on the Apple site. Its worth trying one out for yourself.
 
Your comment on the performance was quite enough for my taste. I can't deal with benchmark numbers anyway. So, I guess the cute thing deserves some savings..
 
Great Review! I really think now I'll be buying one this winter! You've made the design grow on me!
 
I was ready to give away my G4 to my daughter and rush out and order mine after I saw it at the Apple store. It is beautiful and takes up little space. BUT I happened to look it up on EveryMac.com and the stats on the monitor are somewhat disappointing considering this is APPLE not Dell. Contrast ratio 350:1, brightness 200 cd/m and no response time given. Compare these numbers to nearly any of the newer LCD monitors and they look like last year's or worse. Maybe the next rev.
Now I'll have to think about just buying a new monitor instead.
 
That's the magic about Apple or the truth about spec-values: doesn't mean much. I once saw the specs of my powerbook screen and compared to those of other vendors. No chance for my powerbook screen to compete in those numbers. But once I compared my screen to such others of the test, I realized my screen is still a lot brighter and the colours look much more natural. So, leave the numbers and compare. I am positive it will surprise you as well.
 
Ranasta, you can't rely on specs to compare computer equipment. They're guidelines only. The real proof only comes through actually using the product. My impression of the screen is that it is quick enough for an Unreal Frag session without even the slightest blur, sharp, and gives a very wide viewing angle horizontally (a little tight vertically, but unless you plan to sit on the floor to use it you're not going to care). Colour is rich and that contrast is quite good, for a consumer monitor.

I have a severe mistrust of product specifications, they're easily bent around. A perfect example is the dodgy speaker sets they sell at computer swapmeets that are rated as 2000 watts. Its only in the fine print you realise they've measured wattage in a non-conventional way (PMPO instead of RMS).

If we believed product specs we'd be completely taken by the MegaHertz Myth and would ditch Apple completely. Thankfully we're smarter than that. :)
 
Getting into the new iMac G5 is relatively simple. Indeed, most components are consumer serviceable as indicated by Apple's new iMac tech question and service area, and the diagnostic LEDs help isolate problems by the end user. Several steps in the right direction.
 
Back
Top