Mail 2.0.3 Rule For Sent (imap) Mail Not Working


I have 2 aol imap accounts set up in mail. The rules for incoming mail are working and mail is being routed to local folders.
But mail I send is not being copied to the designated local folder for either account.
The rule is: If Any of the following conditions are met:
From. Contains.
Perform the following actions:
Copy Message. to mailbox: AOL yangzone Sent (I navigate to that folder (On My Mac) which I have previously created with New Mailbox menu.

(I started out with "Move Message" which did not work - so now I have "Copy Message")

Any ideas? Maybe there's a better way to go about this?