Usenet Addition Opinion

cfleck

cfleck

tired
I'm not sure when it was added as I can't find an announcement, but it is an insult to this site. Its flooded with the type of behavior that has driven me away from forums before. The trolling, cursing, ignorant behavior has no place here as far as I'm concerned as I was quite happy here prior to its existance.

I know I can hit the "new posts" button that doesn't include the newsgroup, but thats not the point. Quite frankly, I find it embarrasing to even be associated with something that harbors this sort of environment.

Maybe it is my own fault for reading it to begin with, but I can't help but believe it will attact people to the actual site to do the sort of things I mentioned above. Regardless, I've stated my thoughts, so now I'd like to see anyone else's. Write em down!
 
We are still tweaking the importing feature, doing away with a lot of the typical troll posts and off-topic. A majority of these appear to be in the Mac Advocacy group and it is also the biggest, so it requires some work. Plus the importing feature has taken much longer than expected. Still not 100% complete.

The goal is to provide a more filtered Mac newsgroup selection. We have the ability to filter and not import posts that have certain keywords. Of course, until we see the actual threads/posts, we don't know which keywords an this means you will see some content that we would rather not see. Plus, you have the ability to flag any posts/threads and we can take care of it.

I suppose, it would not be to much to give the the option to OPT-OUT of all newsgroups, I will investigate if that can be automated.
 
I've started to exclude most of the postings from the newsgroups since I barely have enough time to read all of what's just included in this site. To add more stuff in there, although a great resource if you are looking for information or assistance (disregarding the annoying trolls), can just be a bit too much to consume for the likes of me, and possibly others.
 
Another comment on this. Frankly i've seen nothing in any of the [NG] threads i'd ever want to read, too much trolling and arguments. The opt out is good, and i have opted out, but i still get [NG] posts when i use the search system (even though this isn't supposed to happen), which is irritating as the volume of posts there swamps the forum posts.


In the end i have to agree with cfleck, i really would prefer this site not to be associated with these newsgroups at all. As an alternative, maybe you could make it a wholly different area of the site, with different logon etc.
 
Well, I did have a period of that if you did opt-out that you may have still got some, but if you are still getting them, please advise. If so, which "forum" are you seeing?
 
Used basic search for 'widget', got results from [NG] Mac Advocacy, [NG] PHP Language 2, [NG] Mac Apps, [NG] Mac System, [NG] Mac Misc, [NG] Mac Programmers Tools, :(
 
I just turned off my access (using the toggle access feature) and did a search on Widget and got no NG results at all. Please check your access first. When you go to the main forum display page, do you see the newsgroups listed?
 
It was already off, but to make sure i turned it on, then off again using the above link, and i still get NG results in my searches. Whether on or off, i see the Newsgroups on the main forum page in a blue block, different form the other forums.
 
I turned it off and I still get [NG] groups when I search for widget. So I see the same thing as another data point.
 
I can't turn them off at all. I click the link in the FAQ, and it says the NG access has been turned on/off, but either way, I see the newsgroups in the main list and they show up in searches.

I appreciate that this feature is useful for searching, but I really don't think it should be so integrated into the regular forum. I'd rather have it be an entirely separate entity, and include an "also search newgroups" check box in the advanced search options. I shouldn't need to go through the enable/disable rigamarole every time I want to perform a search that does or does not include newsgroups (I realize you've always been able to search specific forums in the advanced search window, but deselecting them all is a bit of a hassle).

I've never been much of a newsgroup guy, myself. Part of me thinks "aren't there far better ways of searching newsgroups already out there?" I'm not sure there's really a need for macosx.com to take on this role. That said, as long as it stays out of my way, I won't really care.

Just my 2¢
 
Turning off newsgroups removes your access to them. Meaning, you shouldn't even see them, they should not show up in searches, it is as though they don't exist. Now, if you are logged out, then they will show up, but when you login, they will disappear.

I guess the question now is, is it working for anyone? It works for me just fine. I am having trouble duplicating. It would be nice to see if I am the only one or if others are having the same result I am.
 
I have the newsgroups turned off. Here is a little screen shot of me searching for "widget" and a little screen shot of the newsgroup results that turn up.

Hope it helps.
 

Attachments

  • Picture 1.png
    Picture 1.png
    14.8 KB · Views: 4
  • Picture 2.png
    Picture 2.png
    25.1 KB · Views: 1
If you can see them on the main page, you still see them in results. It's all connected. I don't doubt you are seeing them, just trying to find out why. It works for me.
 
I'm not sure, but I think newsgroup threads are showing up in the RSS feed. Not sure if this intentional or not, but as you can imagine, not a welcome addition for me.

I assume they are usenet feeds as I can't access them when I click the link.

Is it the case that the RSS feed will include the usenet threads?
 
I toggled the newsgroups on and off. It said something to the effect of "removing newsgroup access" and "adding newsgroup access" so I know it toggled. But in every case when the front page refreshed it included the newsgroups.

If you cannot fix the newsgroup thing in the short term is it possible to return more than 100 threads on the "new posts" search. The newsgroups are pushing out the threads I am interested in and I am sure that there are a couple of discussions that I have dropped out of because they were not posted to in the past 12 hours and were pushed off the new list.

I can try to ignore the newsgroups in the meantime.

Thanks.
 
RSS: No Newsgroups
Main Page: No Newsgroups
New Posts (Logged In): No Newsgroups
New Posts [Combined] (Logged In): Includes Newsgroups

If you are getting newsgroups posts in any of the above, except where noted, then clear your browser cache.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top