Graphics Card

evoarts

Registered
I have been given an old Power Mac G5 (1.8GHz PowerPC G5). I wanted to do some simple(ish) upgrading to it it (Ram, Hard Drive etc) but wondered if its worth upgrading the graphics card. If I do can I install any 8 X AGP graphics card or does it have to be a card specifically for a Mac computer?
Many thanks in advance.
 
It has to be a Mac-specific graphics card.

Rumor has it you can "flash" certain PC cards to work in a Mac, but that's always a shot-in-the-dark kind of process. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't, and even if it does work, graphics anomalies are not uncommon.
 
Many thanks for your advice. I'll look into it, its a shame that there isn't as much hardware available and choice for a Mac, plus they tend to cost much more. If anyone can direct me to a good reseller for mac graphics cards that would suite my requirements it'll be much appreciated.
Thanks again.
 
Many thanks for your advice. I'll look into it, its a shame that there isn't as much hardware available and choice for a Mac, plus they tend to cost much more. If anyone can direct me to a good reseller for mac graphics cards that would suite my requirements it'll be much appreciated.
Thanks again.

I do remember hearing a couple of years ago that ATI was moving to having one card support both platforms, or at least have a card that does. Of course, this is directly from ATI, not from a third party using ATI's reference design. Best thing to do is check what platforms are supported exactly by the device.
 
Many thanks for your advice. I'll look into it, its a shame that there isn't as much hardware available and choice for a Mac, plus they tend to cost much more. If anyone can direct me to a good reseller for mac graphics cards that would suite my requirements it'll be much appreciated.
Thanks again.

This is a whole 'nother conversation that has been discussed almost to death, so it doesn't make much sense to dive into it in-depth.

First off, there are TONS of choices for Mac. Any kind of external peripheral that is a mass storage devices (Firewire and USB hard drives) work both on Mac and Windows PCs (as well as Linux!). In terms of graphics cards, yes, selection is limited -- but that's just about where it ends. Hard drives, a lot of PCI cards, monitors, RAM, bluetooth dongles, wireless devices, etc. all work with Mac flawlessly, out-of-the-box. It's always best to do some research and ask around before purchasing something for a Mac (just like you would do if purchasing something for a PC), but I think you'd be surprised at how much stuff is compatible with Mac.

As for the "Macs are expensive" argument, sure: Apple does not produce inexpensive machines... but the machines that they DO sell are no more expensive than a similarly-equipped PC. It's just that while Dell, hp, Acer, Asus and other companies produce bargain-basement computers as well as mid- to high-end computers, Apple only produces the mid- to high-end computers. Configure a Dell with all the specs and hardware of a Mac Pro and you're looking at spending about the same amount (sometimes even more on the PC side).

Can you build a PC cheaper than a Mac? Sure! Will it be apples-to-apples, feature-for-feature the same? Nope.

You can't build a Mac at all. If a person is the type that likes to have control over each component that goes into a computer, then a Mac is not for them.

But I digress... at any rate, http://www.owcomputing.com used to carry video cards (PCI, AGP, PCI-X, PCIe, etc.) for many models of Mac. If you can't find one on their website, a phone call will usually work out.

You can also check out some of the "Deals" links on http://www.lowendmac.com for used Macs and used Mac parts.

Be wary of eBay and Craigslist -- a lot of people like to pass off "flashed" PC-specific cards as "Mac-compatible." I would recommend against these types of cards as results can be unpredictable. I think it best to get a genuinely native Mac graphics card, and yes, Mac-specific graphics cards are more expensive than their PC counterparts -- that's the "more expensive" part that is 100% true.
 
Back
Top