Being licensed in Antigua makes no difference in the United States. Morris Mohawk Gaming Group is based out of Canada -- again, that makes no difference in the United States.
In addition, Bodog's own terms and conditions state that if you intend to wager money, you agree to physically come to Antigua and abide by Antiguan laws.
https://www.bodoglife.com/help/financial/player-agreement.jsp
BY PLACING A WAGER WITH BODOG, THE PLAYER AGREES THAT PLAYER IS, FOR THE PURPOSES OF MAKING ANY WAGERING TRANSACTIONS, DEEMED TO COME TO ANTIGUA, THE JURISDICTION OF RESIDENCE OF BODOG, AND ARE ENTERING INTO TRANSACTIONS IN ANTIGUA UNDER THE LAWS OF ANTIGUA.
THE PLAYER IS RESPONSIBLE FOR OBSERVING GAMBLING PROHIBITIONS OF PLAYER'S RESPECTIVE OR RESIDENT COUNTRY.
That's a simple way to skirt around United States anti-gambling laws. They wouldn't put that in their terms and conditions if it were legal to wager American dollars in online gambling casinos.
Bodog isn't being secretive at all -- you're correct -- in fact, they are saying, out loud, and in clear terms, that any and all activity that occurs on their site concerning wagering and gambling with real money must be done outside of the borders of the United States and Canada, and any other country that has laws preventing the wagering of real money in online casinos. By agreeing to Bodog's terms and conditions, you are agreeing to this, and it is in plain sight when you create an account with them.
While it's true that it may be impossible to find someone who has been prosecuted for online gambling, it is
extremely easy to find people who were denied a payout of their winnings due to the laws of the United States. It's not a fear of being prosecuted, it's a fear of not being able to get back the money you put into the gambling site as well as your winnings.
Credit card companies cannot and will not entertain nor authorize transactions from online gambling casinos. Using PayPal is a way to skirt around those laws.
I'm not trying to say to everyone, "Don't gamble online," I'm simply saying, "Be aware that gambling with American dollars in any kind of off-shore, international, online casino is illegal, and your experience collecting winnings may be adversely affected by this fact."