macbook pro (early 2011) finder hangup issue

ekh23

Registered
Hi,

I'm not exactly tech savvy, so hopefully someone can help me figure out what I should do to fix it, and if there's a way to fix it myself(?)...
I bought a used 13" macbook pro (early 2011), and have had it for about 4 months (the previous owner installed a 500GB SATA, and 8GB ram). I'm asking if there's a way to fix it myself or take it in, as I believe the warranty was void when the previous owner installed the memory and ram himself, and I sadly didn't get the original startup disc from him (I asked for one, but I'm not sure if he gave me a copy from a different computer, as it's not an original bootup disc). That's what I get for not being tech savvy enough, and not doing enough research before the purchase...

But anyways, the computer was working fine for the last few months -- until I updated the software to 10.6.8 recently (or at least I didn't notice any of these problems until after the update).

Normally upon startup, my computer goes pretty quickly through the grey apple screen/blue screen/background wallpaper-finder desktop with icons and dock. I did get an occasional beep/click from the hard drive, but didn't think much of it at the time, spinning beachball and then just did a forced shutdown and cold restart (if those symptoms mean anything too?).

Recently, after the update and upon startup, my computer remains with the grey apple screen with spinner and loading bar for awhile -- the loading bar seems to stop at about 1/8 of the length of the bar (at least 4 minutes+) , then it disappears, and the spinner keeps spinning for another bunch of minutes. When it finally gets past this stage, it goes to blue, then loads my background wallpaper.

However, here are some of the odd symptoms after startup when it gets to the background wallpaper desktop -- there is more than one symptom, hence my getting confused on what could be the reason:

1) No icons appear on the desktop -- no hard drive icon, no folders that were previously saved on the desktop, etc. The desktop is just blank (only the background wallpaper and dock are visible).

2) The cursor is the spinning beachball of death when rolled over the desktop, but becomes a pointer over the menu and the icons in the dock. I can launch programs from the dock, but I cannot create new folders, open windows in the finder to view documents/pictures/files on the hard drive, etc. It's almost like the finder is looping(?) -- somehow it appears it can't access the hard drive(?)
Launching programs from the dock is great, except that I can't do much with the apps -- iTunes can't connect to the internet, etc. Plus I didn't try to save any files, but even if I could, I doubt I could access them with a spinning beachball on the finder... Can't do a forced relaunch of the finder either -- beachball just spins and spins, again without icons on the desktop...

3) Also, before the update, my internal airport extreme was recognized and I could connect and disconnect fine. After the update, upon startup, I got a dialog box saying it couldn't find my connection. I tried to manually type in the network name and password, but it would not retain the information even if I selected the "remember this network" for future use. I also could not connect even if it said it was connected. I had thought this was just a fluke, and did a cold startup the next day, and it happened again. Has happened ever since. :(

---------
Here's what I attempted so far:
I tried to reboot with Verbose screen (cmd-V startup)-- the only thing that stood out to me in the text was a "fail to repair the disc" and that it would try to launch fsck upon next launch (or something to that effect). Then, on another attempt, I also attempted to start it from the copied disc the previous owner gave to me, but when I inserted the disc, shutdown,and then held down the C key upon startup, I got 3 beeps, silence, 3 beeps, silence, etc -- seems it didn't want to start from the disc either. Not sure if that indicates anything either(?)


Has anyone else encountered this problem? I read a number of possibly similar postings, but nothing that combines it all in one occurrence on a computer... I read something that said the finder's spinning beachball could be from bad RAM, but it seems maybe it's more than that(?)

If anyone could possibly help me with this issue, or shed some light on what might be happening with my computer it'd be much appreciated --even if it's bad news...:(

Many thanks in advance for your help,
E
ps.I also backed up everything on Time Machine when I first got the computer, so if I did need to reinstall the OS (and was informed how to go about doing that), a future step would be to see if I could recover the original state of programs etc from Time Machine...
 
The warranty on your MacBook Pro is not void, simply because of replacing the hard drive and adding RAM memory. The only way that would happen is if there is actual damage caused by the upgrades.
However, the 3-beeps during boot indicates a memory problem, so you should try reseating the RAM in the slots. If the beeping continues after trying that, then the memory may be faulty, and you should try replacing the memory completely.

You should try booting while holding the Shift key, which will boot to Safe Boot mode. That may allow you to delete the com.apple.Finder.plist file.

But, you mentioned that you could hear the hard drive clicking occasionally - and hardware noises from a hard drive is just not good news. You need to check that some more, by booting to an OS X install disk (can you boot to the one that you got with the MacBook Pro?), and running Disk Utility from the Utilities menu. If that will not pass a Repair Disk, then you either need to replace that hard drive, or try a more capable disk repair app, such as Disk Warrior.
 
Here's what I attempted so far:
I tried to reboot with Verbose screen (cmd-V startup)-- the only thing that stood out to me in the text was a "fail to repair the disc" and that it would try to launch fsck upon next launch (or something to that effect). Then, on another attempt, I also attempted to start it from the copied disc the previous owner gave to me, but when I inserted the disc, shutdown,and then held down the C key upon startup, I got 3 beeps, silence, 3 beeps, silence, etc -- seems it didn't want to start from the disc either. Not sure if that indicates anything either(?)

The "failed to repair disk" indicates there is a problem with the directory structure that disk utility cannot repair. It could very well be corrected by using a third party utility like Disk Warrior or you may need a new drive.

While booting from the "copied disk" and getting the beep codes means the machine is not accepting that copied disk as a bootable volume. The beeps can mean memory also, but its likely that disk the machine doesn't like.
 
Thanks DeltaMac & djackmac -- I'll attempt both suggestions and update this thread with the results hopefully later in the week.

Thanks again,
E
 
Hi again,

The update: Still no resolution yet. Borrowed friend's iMac to format a new drive, partitioned the drive, upload the OS X copied disc (10.6) the previous owner gave me, and tried to boot from external, but MBP doesn't seem to like external bootup either(?) The external was recognized though while holding down OPT key upon startup. It just didn't want to boot (3 beeps,pause,3 beeps,etc). Again, not sure if it's because the new drive was formatted by a different mac (and version of Snow Leopard) than the corrupt old drive is in, and so the MBP might not like it(?) Or if I need a firewire 800 connection rather than the usb to get it to work...

If I don't have a copy of the original SnowLeopard disc, can I get one from Apple again (I know it'd cost money, but I'd pay if it'll help me reinstall SL)? Or would I need to be the original owner who bought the computer to get a replacement disc (I don't know if he registered the serial under his apple id or not)?

I also ran DiskWarrior from dvd -- and it also told me the directory was severely damaged and that it scavenged for files and folders. I was debating on rebuilding the directory -- if I do so, and the drive still didn't work, would I still be able to bring it in to a computer specialist place to try to "salvage" any programs/applications on the drive? Or should I just NOT rebuild it and bring it to the specialist anyways to see if he can salvage something, like any of the applications? Or skip taking it to a specialist?

(The good thing about using DW was that I was able to at least copy over some photos and text files from the preview window in DW to another external drive (USB)). It's just that I want to see if I can get any of the programs extracted from the hard drive (if possible).

Sorry for different thoughts about how to go about this -- I am someone who wants to be optimistic, even when things look pretty grim ;p

Any thoughts/suggestions much appreciated. Thanks again.

E
 
The update: Still no resolution yet. Borrowed friend's iMac to format a new drive, partitioned the drive, upload the OS X copied disc (10.6) the previous owner gave me, and tried to boot from external, but MBP doesn't seem to like external bootup either(?) The external was recognized though while holding down OPT key upon startup. It just didn't want to boot (3 beeps,pause,3 beeps,etc). Again, not sure if it's because the new drive was formatted by a different mac (and version of Snow Leopard) than the corrupt old drive is in, and so the MBP might not like it(?) Or if I need a firewire 800 connection rather than the usb to get it to work...

Yeah, target disk mode requires firewire.

If I don't have a copy of the original SnowLeopard disc, can I get one from Apple again (I know it'd cost money, but I'd pay if it'll help me reinstall SL)?

Yes, that's going to be your best bet.

I also ran DiskWarrior from dvd -- and it also told me the directory was severely damaged and that it scavenged for files and folders. I was debating on rebuilding the directory -- if I do so, and the drive still didn't work, would I still be able to bring it in to a computer specialist place to try to "salvage" any programs/applications on the drive? Or should I just NOT rebuild it and bring it to the specialist anyways to see if he can salvage something, like any of the applications? Or skip taking it to a specialist?

(The good thing about using DW was that I was able to at least copy over some photos and text files from the preview window in DW to another external drive (USB)). It's just that I want to see if I can get any of the programs extracted from the hard drive (if possible).

If you want to keep programs, the best bet is to make a disk image of the DiskWarrior preview, then once the machine is up and running with a fresh OSX install use migration assistant to migrate the apps and data back in. Drag and drop rarely ever works if you are trying to move apps. But seems like the drive is going. The sure way to tell with DiskWarrior is at step 5 (locating directory data stage) if it says "speed reduced by disk malfunction" then the drive is on its way out.
 
Thanks djackmac --

Luckily I didn't see the "malfunction" warning during the DW preview details... But thanks for the heads up. Will keep an eye on that as I do periodic DW checks of the MBP.

So, here's the latest list of attempts and to jump to the point -- let me just say thank goodness the DiskWarrior Rebuilding of my drive's directory solved my dilemma- partially.
(of course after nearly giving up and sounding like a dodo and freaking out on here, like all others who have never experienced this freeze problem before and don't know jack about fixing these kind of things) ;p

But, I still don't like how the drive sounds... :-/

After reading the details of DiskWarrior's review of my drive's directory and "repairing" a number of things (the details were quite long), I finally just bit the bullet and let DW rebuild the directory. After it was finished and the computer was restarted, I was able to get it to boot up and had a normal desktop with icons on it, launched some programs, saved a few small files to test the system -- the only thing changed was the date/time, which had to be reset, as did the wireless network info. Even though I had a few good signs of the drive working, I now know by this "reality check" that I will need to do something more than just go back to using the computer as normal...

Also, the network settings are not recognized when rebooting subsequent times. odd.

Now that I have the drive up and running at least, and am more wary of backing up what I have, my next step will be to clone the drive or at least figure out how to back up the applications since copying over to an external in DW preview mode copying doesn't want to work...

Also, although I bought the MBP used and lacked the original discs, I was able to contact Apple and they said they would send me replacement install discs (even outside of "my" expired warranty) -- which was good news. So I should have those soon and will definitely keep both the install discs and DW close by, just in case...

I have a few SATA drives now, thanks to buying one and another friend donating his extra one to me, and ordering an extra enclosure with fw & usb connection ports for the cloning. I'll be looking on here for more details on how to clone a drive's contents and also reading up more on the suggestions you gave, djackmac. Thanks again for your help.

Best,
E
 
Back
Top