Viro said:
That's like complaining that you can't delete libc on a Unix system because the apps will break. What is your gripe with webkit?
No, that's a big difference as libc is open source and I can replace it, change the source code or whatever I want. I can't just disable or edit some webkit functions. And as there are some security issues with the webkit all apps that uses it are vulnerable and I can't change this without breaking allthese apps. And waiting until Apple closes these holes is like hoping that Microsoft gets Windows fixed.
Just take the (very easy to fix) mRouter vulnerability. This one is a really huge hole with exploits available for download. And I KNOW that this already got exploited in some schools to modify/look at files as 'root'. If Apple would provide the sources everyone can fix this but so the only thing you can do is remove the suid flag or remove mRouter completly. And to make it even better I 've got a working trojan on my testsystem that exploit this (for over 2 month unfixed) and automatlically send itself to every mail address it can find in any users addressbook.
So If anyone tell you there aren't any viruses/trojans for OS X they're just lying. They are just not (known) out in the wild as they're created to test and fix these things locally.
I can understand that Tiger has priority for Apple developers but they should know that OS X can just survive if it's a stable and secure OS because this is the only real reason why many 'pros' use it. If it's unsecure I can easily switch to Windows.
I don't wan't to have (in my eyes needless) features like dashboard (I can use Konfab if I wish to have this) or Spotlight. I know what I have written and I can use locate and grep (not the old versions Apple supply) to search. The only reason why I use OS X is the availability of good apps in combination with stability and safety. And because I can clearly see that Apple don't care about the last one (at least not more than MS does) I stick with my in various ways enhanced darwin kernel/os.
My hope is that Apple make the OS more open and modular so that everyone can choose what he want to have. If I can easily remove (completely) Spotlight, Dashboard, Webkit and all the apps like Safari, Mail, iChat, iPhoto.. I maybe install 10.5 if it's more open source than 10.3 is.