Transition to new MacBook question

justalink

Registered
I just purchased a new 15" MacBook Pro and will be transferring all of my stuff from my old MacBook Pro (circa 2006). I'm currently running 10.6.8 and have no immediate plans to use Lion on the new machine (I have some legacy apps that I'd rather not lose). So I plan to load Snow Leopard on the new machine but my question is about transferring files.

Should I clean install 10.6.8 on the new machine and use Migration Assistant or should I transfer the entire contents of the old laptop using my SuperDuper backup from an external drive? I don't want to transfer any bugs/quirks to the new computer but I would like to get up and running as soon as possible without having to reload/re-register a bunch of stuff.

Thanks in advance,
Justin
 
You are welcome to try any technique, I suppose.
Keep in mind that you may not be successful...
Your new MacBook Pro model was released after Lion was released, and Apple tends to make minor changes to the logic board which are driver-specific, and OS X version specific.
The best method, I think, to try this out, is to connect the old and new MacBook Pros together with Firewire.
Start your old MacBook Pro, holding the letter T to boot into firewire Target Disk Mode. You'll see that firewire icon floating on the screen.
Now, Option-boot the new MacBook Pro. Does your old MBPro hard drive show up, in addition to the hard drive on you new one? If the old HD appears, choose it, then press enter. If it boots successfully to the old hard drive, then you should be great. It will also be very simple to do. Run your Disk Utility, erase the hard drive on your new one, by choosing the Partition tab, and selecting One Partition from the drop-down. That will remove the hidden Lion recovery partition, and allow you to use all the space on the hard drive. When that completes, choose the Restore tab, then drag your old hard drive into the Source window, and the newly blank hard drive into the destination window, then click Restore. Your complete old hard drive will be transferred to the new MBPro hard drive.
When that's complete, restart to the new system, which will, for the moment, be identical to your old MBPro.
You won't be able to easily compensate for possible video or audio, or other hardware issues that appear because you are using an older system on newer hardware, which will be unsupported by Apple.

Or - you may find that you can't even boot your new MBPro to the older system, and you get to stay with Lion. It's all fine... :D
 
The new macbook pro will not run 10.6.8. Sorry to break it to you but I run into University IT folks wanting to run versions of OSX that are older than the hardware at least once a week and it just doesn't work (unless maybe you can do it through virtualization). But stand alone or even on a separate partition it ain't happening.
 
It will. Mine is.
88ac5dea.gif


I used the SuperDuper! transfer. Granted make sure you have a clean clone. I assume you have no problems with your previous computer, but if there is any "crap" you do not want, you might as well get rid of it.

Due to both paranoia and circumstances, I have more than one Ex-HD and clone daily with SuperDuper!. Yay. Praise me. PRAISE ME! [Get on with it!--Ed.]

What I did was, of course, back everything up. I thought my older Macbook was dead as in logic board dead. It decided to start working again . . . it has done this before. Rather than waste $$$ replacing what seemed obvious, I upgraded. I blather that because djackmac may not be completely wrong: you and I have unique circumstances: two working Macbooks.

Technically, I could have taken my relatively new Int-HD in my OLD Macbook which is BETTER
brood.gif
and [Get on with it!--Ed.] right in my current Macbook but that made the dealer's head explode--he cannot sell a computer without a HD.
b7dc1e9e.gif


If you want to be super-safe have TWO Ex-HD. That way, migration assistant your Current You from Clone I--let it update, let Lion update. Yay.

Now clone that back to Clone I. This is "You" in Lion. Maybe you will like it. Maybe not, but if everything goes wrong and djackmac and Delta start dancing the "I Told You So!" dance, you can simply go back. Obviously, or not so obviously, you are cloning the YOU partition and NOT the Lion recovery.

Do not touch the Lion Recovery Partition. Leave it alone. It is happy. You are happy. We are all happy. Except for Cleveland.

Neat! Now I could actually BOOT my updated Mac from my Snow Leopard clones. So I simply booted from a clone--your Clone II. I then opened Disk Utility, erased
freakingout.gif
the Lion YOU--leaving, of course, the Recovery Partition. Format the partition, name it and all of that.

Now use SuperDuper! to simply cleanly clone Clone II to your You Partition. Ta-dah!

There are easier ways of doing this, but this avoids the consequences of frell-ups.

At any time you wish to go to Lion . . . and we all will . . . someday . . .
63f9e718.gif
. . . you can either go to your Recovery Partition and recover. I have done that . . . twice . . . testing it.

Or you can use your Lion clone, but it will be a few weeks/months old and not have your latest French Fungus Porn.
f2c60b08.gif


HOWEVER [No shouting!--Ed.]

One issue you will have is if you want a stand-alone Lion on a "stick" or DVD as the Local Here-Tell. See, I had every intention of plopping down the $30 for Lion until I had to upgrade the computer, and discovered the issues Lion has which I "don't wike."
1e3ad5d2.gif


So . . . like . . . can I . . . you know . . . convert my Lion Recovery to . . . you know . . . a "stick." Apparently not. You still have to BUY Lion and do all of that. Granted IF you have clones, you really do not have to worry about recovery unless you are trapped on an island/basement without your clones and you need to recover something. But that is what your Recovery Partition is for.

Now where djackmac is correct is if you simply boot on your Snow Leopard DVD and try to load it, you will get the "No Chance Fat Pig!" response. I did not bother erasing with SL DVD Disk Utility and then trying, but I suspect that does not work somehow.

Again, you and I are unique in that we have bootable clones. Which is why I rant and rave about the utility of spray cheese and a good defense against a two-front war . . . no . . . wait . . . why I rant about creating bootable clones.

You could do this with one clone, obviously, but on the odd chance the 15" does not boot while the 13" does, you are stuck having to erase and recover from the Lion Partition.

emot-eng101.gif


--J.D.
 
Just remember don't transfer the Network settings! The network settings from Snow Leopard to Lion was changed slightly. So just right down your network settings when getting the new Mac and putting in the Network settings manually.

IMHO this will prevent a lot of future networking headaches.
 
Oy vey. I had no idea. Thanks for the article link!
__________________
The new macbook pro will not run 10.6.8. Sorry to break it to you but I run into University IT folks wanting to run versions of OSX that are older than the hardware at least once a week and it just doesn't work (unless maybe you can do it through virtualization). But stand alone or even on a separate partition it ain't happening.
 
Back
Top