I'm not "taking sides" here, and I'm not going to state my official opinion on this subject either but:
The user couldn't give a **** if they have to scroll down two clicks or not. It kind of goes along with the topic of setting a pre-defined resolution for your website. For example: if you're designing a webpage in Photoshop under a resolution of 2000x1700 you'll see your page a lot differently than somebody with say a resolution of 800x600. So let's say you decide to set your resolution to 800x600 and make the website, but then what happens to the users with resolutions over 1026x768?
Now so you, and I, can sleep good tonight I'll say this: you can't please everybody. That's the way the world is. Make something so it fits in the average spot and people will view it as above-average. Make something look above-average and it will look awful.