Lt Major Burns said:
Minimize/windowshade.
I hated windowshade. remove the window from my workspace, so i can see what i'm doing. what are you doing...? why is the bloody title bar still there? bloody hell! i have 10 title bars still present!.
i HATE windowshade. one of the reasons why Classic needed to become classic.
minimize GENUINELY gets the windows out of the way for a bit. and only a bit. it doesn't become a dock resident, for gods sake. it's so useful for preserving a window for a bit, or just getting out of the way without hiding it fully, and it still tells you it's there (why is there too much by the trash? ah! i remember!)
it also looks good.
Fair enough. Now I'll tell you why I hate the Dock, and loved WindowShade:
99% of the time I want to collapse a window, it's because I'm
still working with it. I just want it out of my way briefly usually less than a second just so I can see/access something behind it real quick. Then I want my window back. With WindowShade, BOOM! Out of my way, and back in focus in a split second.
With the Dock, I have to minimize it, then watch it go through its sucking effect rigamarole (which is an annoying time waster, but, of course, it's necessary when the window is going to an arbitrary location like the Dock), see/get what I want, then go hunting for it in the Dock to get it back. Ugh.
I only consider the Dock's minimization useful for long-term "storage" of windows. (I am tech-ifying the phrase "long-term" to mean "more than a minute".
) For that, it's great, and it blows WindowShade out of the water. But for what I used WindowShade for most, the Dock fails miserably.
Which is exactly my point: the Dock is not a good
replacement. Great supplement, poor substitute.
Of course, now that we have Exposé, I don't find myself hurting for the lack of WindowShade nearly as much. I still wish I could accomplish what WindowShade did, but now I think more in terms of "I'd like a new Exposé mode" rather than "I want WindowShade back".