First off, let me say this. In OS 9, you could open an app in ONE CLICK. Click and hold on the Apple menu, drag down to the application you want, and release the mouse button. 1 click
With the dock, you also only need one click. Move your mouse down to where the dock is, it unhides. No click yet. Move to the application you want to launch. No click yet. When you find it, *click*. Again, 1 click. Where in the WORLD do you guys get 3 clicks to launch an app from the dock or two from the Apple menu (actually, I know how you got the Apple menu one because if you click and release on a menu it stays open, so you can do it in 2 clicks, but you don't need to). Keep it simple guys.
Now what i don't understand is how people can complain about the dock when it's so simple to make an Apple menu in it. Solution: Make a folder. Drop all the apps you want in your "Apple Menu". Get info on the folder and change the icon to an Apple. Drag the folder to the right side of your dock. There. You HAVE AN APPLE MENU. There's no way that you can't have an Apple menu with the dock, because you can still click-and-hold on the folder and get a list of contents ALPHABETICALLY. How the HECK is this different from the Apple menu other than the location? (Hint: It ISN'T)
Sheesh. It's not that hard to make an Apple menu with the dock.